"JOSEPH---ANY DREAM WILL DO"
-
Lena & Harry Smith
- Posts: 21514
- Joined: Tue Jul 12, 2005 10:05 am
- Location: London UK
I was a bit disappointed with most of the songs chosen tonight-I did not really like any of them.
I still think Lee and Daniel are the best.
But a big surprise to see Seamus go---it did not make sense as one minute Craig had the lowest number of votes---then he was saved by ALW--then leapfrogged over Seamus and Ben to be safe. No wonder Seamus was surprised--and annoyed--he mentioned about a "Conspiracy theory". On the web-site , it was assumed he said it as a joke--but I do not think so--he threw his coat off himself, and changed the last words to the final song. I think he was furious. I do not blame him--something went wrong tonight.
I still think Lee and Daniel are the best.
But a big surprise to see Seamus go---it did not make sense as one minute Craig had the lowest number of votes---then he was saved by ALW--then leapfrogged over Seamus and Ben to be safe. No wonder Seamus was surprised--and annoyed--he mentioned about a "Conspiracy theory". On the web-site , it was assumed he said it as a joke--but I do not think so--he threw his coat off himself, and changed the last words to the final song. I think he was furious. I do not blame him--something went wrong tonight.
Mariana
-
Lena & Harry Smith
- Posts: 21514
- Joined: Tue Jul 12, 2005 10:05 am
- Location: London UK
It seemed surprising that Seamus was voted off but ALW did mention twice last night that he was concerned why, in view of his age and supposedly stage and theatre experience he hadn't got further.
Although the voting is done by the viewers, ALW and the judges are with the entrants during the week and get to know them fairly well.
It seemed from comments too that Seamus was at times making the other entrants feel inferior and less talented.
We wondered if Craig and Keith's accent could go against them when it comes to dialogue on stage.
We have a problem trying to understand Ally MCcoist
on Question Of Sport, particularly when people are laughing and we don't know what for.
Does anyone else have this problem
Anyway we also think Lee and Daniel are in with the best chance.
Although the voting is done by the viewers, ALW and the judges are with the entrants during the week and get to know them fairly well.
It seemed from comments too that Seamus was at times making the other entrants feel inferior and less talented.
We wondered if Craig and Keith's accent could go against them when it comes to dialogue on stage.
We have a problem trying to understand Ally MCcoist
on Question Of Sport, particularly when people are laughing and we don't know what for.Does anyone else have this problem
Anyway we also think Lee and Daniel are in with the best chance.
I must admit, wasn't too keen on any of the song choices either last night. I also agree it was strange how Seamus got voted off. I liked him but really he appeared a little too old for the part, although of course Joseph does age as the story progresses. I like Rob too and Daniel, but they look older too, even if they aren't! I'm sticking with my favourite from the start and that is Lee, with Keith as my second choice.
Marian
Marian
Good show again tonight--I think Chris was long overdue to go.
I think everone seems to think it is between Lee, Keith and Daniel-and I am still betting on Lee as I think he has the more experience , and doing 8 shows a week is going to be tough.
Saw on the teletext that the winner will be singing at the "Princess Diana" tribute on July 1st---does not give him much time--still 7 singers in the competition!!
I think everone seems to think it is between Lee, Keith and Daniel-and I am still betting on Lee as I think he has the more experience , and doing 8 shows a week is going to be tough.
Saw on the teletext that the winner will be singing at the "Princess Diana" tribute on July 1st---does not give him much time--still 7 singers in the competition!!
Mariana
-
Lena & Harry Smith
- Posts: 21514
- Joined: Tue Jul 12, 2005 10:05 am
- Location: London UK
Yes, It was a good show tonight. We thought that Daniel, Keith and Ben were the best tonight.
Lee has the experience but although it is supposed to be the viewers votes, ALW could have the same thoughts that he had about Seamus, like... Why hasn't he made further progress by now.
ALW was worried about Chris too.
We imagined that an ambulance would have to be on standby for Chris if he was voted off.
Lee has the experience but although it is supposed to be the viewers votes, ALW could have the same thoughts that he had about Seamus, like... Why hasn't he made further progress by now.
ALW was worried about Chris too.
We imagined that an ambulance would have to be on standby for Chris if he was voted off.
I thought Keith stood out as the best last night, though Ben and Craig definately had the best stamina when it came to the "On the Barricade" test! I'd not thought of how fit physically singers have to be for some of these demanding Stage Musicals.
My favourite Lee, rather fell by the wayside tonight
Marian
I'd not thought of how fit physically singers have to be for some of these demanding Stage Musicals. My favourite Lee, rather fell by the wayside tonight
Marian
Joseph Any Dream will do
Tough decisions on the singing, but I think I will vote for Keith !
Angela
I was sorry to see "Rob the Bulder" go--although I have to say that I never saw him as Joseph.
I loved Lee again--he really is a lovely singer--but to my surprise the star of the show was Craig---he had a really strong song to sing--"This is my moment" and he made the most of it---I cannot understand why they do not all sing Musical songs, as they are to be starring in a musical--I had the same criticism of the "Maria" show. There are more than enough musical numbers to include--I thought some of the other songs were very weak, and Craig showed , that by singing a strong song, it makes all the difference.
Still backing Lee to win.
I loved Lee again--he really is a lovely singer--but to my surprise the star of the show was Craig---he had a really strong song to sing--"This is my moment" and he made the most of it---I cannot understand why they do not all sing Musical songs, as they are to be starring in a musical--I had the same criticism of the "Maria" show. There are more than enough musical numbers to include--I thought some of the other songs were very weak, and Craig showed , that by singing a strong song, it makes all the difference.
Still backing Lee to win.
Mariana
-
Lena & Harry Smith
- Posts: 21514
- Joined: Tue Jul 12, 2005 10:05 am
- Location: London UK
It was a really good show last night, some great songs.
Lee sang exceptionall well, and so did Keith.
Craig came out of his shell at last, and could surprise us all. He looks a Joseph too somehow.
We thought that Rob was going to be voted off, even though he actually sang better than Lewis in the final sing off.
Rob has a problem singing and moving around at the same time. Once again we couldn't hear the words that he was singing.
Ben is an all rounder, has great natural style and is good to watch.
It's getting better week by week
Lee sang exceptionall well, and so did Keith.
Craig came out of his shell at last, and could surprise us all. He looks a Joseph too somehow.
We thought that Rob was going to be voted off, even though he actually sang better than Lewis in the final sing off.
Rob has a problem singing and moving around at the same time.
Once again we couldn't hear the words that he was singing. Ben is an all rounder, has great natural style and is good to watch.
It's getting better week by week
I cannot believe that lovely Daniel has gone---he was in my top 3 to be Joseph, and I thought, apart from Lee had the best voice--and he was just amazing in the sing-off!! Whatever was ALW thinking of--this is about the 3rd time that Lewis has been in the sing-offs---does that not tell him something !!!!!
Mariana
