Post
by paul jh » Fri Aug 03, 2007 3:13 pm
Thanks for listening to Anne Shelton, Robert. I only heard of her a few months ago and have only heard a few recordings. But everything I've heard I have loved.
I partially agree with you on definitive recordings. For instance, the best recording of Blue Moon I've ever heard is Matt Monro's (on The Rare Monro). However, I wouldn't label it definitive as that song has been recorded so many times and I haven't heard all of them. Plus I know that some people may not care for his improvisation of the melody. However, we can all safely say that the definitive recording of Walk Away is by Matt Monro. I also feel he recorded the definitive version of When Joanna Loved Me, but some people may consider Tony Bennett's version to be the definitive version. Even though I've only heard a few recordings of The Green Leaves Of Summer, I would categorically state that Matt Monro's version is the definitive, because it is so emotional and beautiful.