X FACTOR 2011

[mariana44]

Well, it had to come round , didn't it--I do not think there is already a thread for this.

I have to say, that I am not impressed with many of the singers who we have seen. I also think some bad decisions were made on who stayed and who went home.

I could not pick a winner---apparetly Janet is the favourite, but I really do not like her voice.

The one I would love to do well is Jonny---he is a little whacky, but he has a voice that I really like--- I want to see him out of his bed-sit into a place of his own----plus he is different--all the others look and sound the same almost !!

[Sandra]

I agree Marian.The one we predicted to win was the big girl with glasses from Scotland and Kelly Rowland sent her home

[mariana44]

That was Jade---I cannot understand it--they raved over her in the beginning---and half of the girls in the final 8, I do not remember evenseeing in the earlier stages--and at least 2 of them that went through were instantly forgettable.

Definately Jade should have gone through.

[john]

I haven't watched any of it this time around.

[Lena & Harry Smith]

From what we've gathered you and us alike haven't missed much John.

[mariana44]

Oh dear---it was Rock Week tonight on X Factor--I hated it---the only one I liked was Johnny.

Even the judges started bickering with each other.

[mariana44]

Well-I did not think it could get worse--but it has--just a travesty of how this show used to be--the worst singer of all is still hanging on there--the judges still bickering. I am not sure why I am still watching it---it is like watching a programme slowly fading away.

[ROBERT M.]

Frankie has been booted out of the show

[Marian]

I believe he broke the rules!

[mariana44]

To me he broke the rules by being there--he just could not sing.

Maybe we can get some credibilty back on this show---and the only fair thing to do is to bring Johnny and "The risk" back, to give them another chance.

I think Gary made an awful mistake in choosing Frankie to go through.

[Marian]

Apparently it was swearing on air and late night boozing, as well as not being able to sing Marian!

[Sandra]

I agree Marian -bring back The Risk and Johnny

[mariana44]

I had read about all Frankie's antics on and off stage, so he HAD to go.

I just read that they are thinking of bringing back the first 4 that were knocked out in the first round, and for one of them to have another chance.

I think again, they are making a big mistake--Johnny was very popular--
and if things had been as they should ahve been last week, Johnyy should still be in the contest.

Simon must be tearing his hair out--lots of publicity for the show---but all bad, bad, bad.

For those of you who have not caught it yet, try American X factor tonight--some really good singers on there---and compared to ours they are just great !! Plus--so far--no bickering judges. !!

[mariana44]

Nearly at the end of another series--so who is going tonight--doers anyone really care ? I don't.

I think Misha toi win ,as she has the best voice.


Has anyone heard the charity single from X factor, with JLS, and One Direction. Called "Wishing on a star" originally by Rose Royce--and I have to say , for the first time ever, I just love this charity single--a great song and a great version.

[mariana44]

This is really bizarre---both X Factor, and x factor USA, could be won, by someone who was eliminated at an early stage, but brought back.

X Factor USA's Melanie, did not go through to the Live shows, until Simon decided he had made a mistake, and went into the live finals with 5, instead of 4 singers.

X factor UK of course has Amelia, knocked out in the very first round, and bought back after Frankie left.

These 2 both have a very good chance of winning. How unusual is that !!

Still not sure how Little Mix is still in it !